Finance (No. 2) Bill: Reasoned Amendment to Second Reading (Opposition)
Party breakdown
| Party | Aye | No |
|---|---|---|
| Conservative | 100 | — |
| Democratic Unionist Party | 4 | — |
| Independent | 3 | 3 |
| Labour | — | 297 |
| Labour (Co-op) | — | 36 |
| Reform UK | 7 | — |
| Traditional Unionist Voice | 1 | — |
| Ulster Unionist Party | 1 | — |
Ayes 116
- Alan Mak Contact Havant
- Alberto Costa Contact South Leicestershire
- Alex Burghart Contact Brentwood and Ongar
- Alison Griffiths Contact Bognor Regis and Littlehampton
- Andrew Bowie Contact West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
- Andrew Griffith Contact Arundel and South Downs
- Aphra Brandreth Contact Chester South and Eddisbury
- Ben Obese-Jecty Contact Huntingdon
- Blake Stephenson Contact Mid Bedfordshire
- Bob Blackman Contact Harrow East
- Bradley Thomas Contact Bromsgrove
- Charlie Dewhirst Contact Bridlington and The Wolds
- Chris Philp Contact Croydon South
- Claire Coutinho Contact East Surrey
- Dame Caroline Dinenage Contact Gosport
- Dame Harriett Baldwin Contact West Worcestershire
- Dame Karen Bradley Contact Staffordshire Moorlands
- Damian Hinds Contact East Hampshire
- David Davis Contact Goole and Pocklington
- David Mundell Contact Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
- David Reed Contact Exmouth and Exeter East
- David Simmonds Contact Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner
- Dr Andrew Murrison Contact South West Wiltshire
- Dr Kieran Mullan Contact Bexhill and Battle
- Dr Luke Evans Contact Hinckley and Bosworth
- Dr Neil Hudson Contact Epping Forest
- Dr Neil Shastri-Hurst Contact Solihull West and Shirley
- Edward Argar Contact Melton and Syston
- Gareth Bacon Contact Orpington
- Gareth Davies Contact Grantham and Bourne
- George Freeman Contact Mid Norfolk
- Graham Stuart Contact Beverley and Holderness
- Greg Smith Contact Mid Buckinghamshire
- Gregory Stafford Contact Farnham and Bordon
- Helen Grant Contact Maidstone and Malling
- Jack Rankin Contact Windsor
- James Cartlidge Contact South Suffolk
- James Wild Contact North West Norfolk
- Jerome Mayhew Contact Broadland and Fakenham
- Joe Robertson Contact Isle of Wight East
- John Cooper Contact Dumfries and Galloway
- John Glen Contact Salisbury
- John Lamont Contact Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk
- Joy Morrissey Contact Beaconsfield
- Julia Lopez Contact Hornchurch and Upminster
- Katie Lam Contact Weald of Kent
- Kevin Hollinrake Contact Thirsk and Malton
- Kit Malthouse Contact North West Hampshire
- Laura Trott Contact Sevenoaks
- Lincoln Jopp Contact Spelthorne
- Mark Garnier Contact Wyre Forest
- Mark Pritchard Contact The Wrekin
- Martin Vickers Contact Brigg and Immingham
- Matt Vickers Contact Stockton West
- Mike Wood Contact Kingswinford and South Staffordshire
- Mims Davies Contact East Grinstead and Uckfield
- Mr Andrew Snowden Contact Fylde
- Mr Gagan Mohindra Contact South West Hertfordshire
- Mr Mark Francois Contact Rayleigh and Wickford
- Mr Peter Bedford Contact Mid Leicestershire
- Mr Richard Holden Contact Basildon and Billericay
- Mrs Kemi Badenoch Contact North West Essex
- Neil O'Brien Contact Harborough, Oadby and Wigston
- Nick Timothy Contact West Suffolk
- Nigel Huddleston Contact Droitwich and Evesham
- Paul Holmes Contact Hamble Valley
- Peter Fortune Contact Bromley and Biggin Hill
- Priti Patel Contact Witham
- Rebecca Harris Contact Castle Point
- Rebecca Smith Contact South West Devon
- Richard Fuller Contact North Bedfordshire
- Robbie Moore Contact Keighley and Ilkley
- Saqib Bhatti Contact Meriden and Solihull East
- Sarah Bool Contact South Northamptonshire
- Shivani Raja Contact Leicester East
- Simon Hoare Contact North Dorset
- Sir Alec Shelbrooke Contact Wetherby and Easingwold
- Sir Bernard Jenkin Contact Harwich and North Essex
- Sir Christopher Chope Contact Christchurch
- Sir Desmond Swayne Contact New Forest West
- Sir Edward Leigh Contact Gainsborough
- Sir Gavin Williamson Contact Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge
- Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Contact North Cotswolds
- Sir Geoffrey Cox Contact Torridge and Tavistock
- Sir Iain Duncan Smith Contact Chingford and Woodford Green
- Sir James Cleverly Contact Braintree
- Sir Jeremy Hunt Contact Godalming and Ash
- Sir Jeremy Wright Contact Kenilworth and Southam
- Sir John Hayes Contact South Holland and The Deepings
- Sir John Whittingdale Contact Maldon
- Sir Julian Lewis Contact New Forest East
- Sir Julian Smith Contact Skipton and Ripon
- Sir Mel Stride Contact Central Devon
- Sir Oliver Dowden Contact Hertsmere
- Sir Roger Gale Contact Herne Bay and Sandwich
- Steve Barclay Contact North East Cambridgeshire
- Stuart Anderson Contact South Shropshire
- Stuart Andrew Contact Daventry
- Tom Tugendhat Contact Tonbridge
- Victoria Atkins Contact Louth and Horncastle
- Carla Lockhart Contact Upper Bann
- Gavin Robinson Contact Belfast East
- Jim Shannon Contact Strangford
- Mr Gregory Campbell Contact East Londonderry
- Alex Easton Contact North Down
- Mr Adnan Hussain Contact Blackburn
- Patrick Spencer Contact Central Suffolk and North Ipswich
- Andrew Rosindell Contact Romford
- Danny Kruger Contact East Wiltshire
- Lee Anderson Contact Ashfield
- Nigel Farage Contact Clacton
- Richard Tice Contact Boston and Skegness
- Robert Jenrick Contact Newark
- Sarah Pochin Contact Runcorn and Helsby
- Jim Allister Contact North Antrim
- Robin Swann Contact South Antrim
Noes 336
- Dan Norris Contact North East Somerset and Hanham
- Joani Reid Contact East Kilbride and Strathaven
- Ms Diane Abbott Contact Hackney North and Stoke Newington
- Abtisam Mohamed Contact Sheffield Central
- Adam Jogee Contact Newcastle-under-Lyme
- Adam Thompson Contact Erewash
- Al Carns Contact Birmingham Selly Oak
- Alan Strickland Contact Newton Aycliffe and Spennymoor
- Alex Baker Contact Aldershot
- Alex Ballinger Contact Halesowen
- Alex Davies-Jones Contact Pontypridd
- Alex Mayer Contact Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard
- Alex McIntyre Contact Gloucester
- Alison Hume Contact Scarborough and Whitby
- Alison McGovern Contact Birkenhead
- Alison Taylor Contact Paisley and Renfrewshire North
- Alistair Strathern Contact Hitchin
- Amanda Hack Contact North West Leicestershire
- Amanda Martin Contact Portsmouth North
- Andrew Cooper Contact Mid Cheshire
- Andrew Lewin Contact Welwyn Hatfield
- Andrew Ranger Contact Wrexham
- Andrew Western Contact Stretford and Urmston
- Andy MacNae Contact Rossendale and Darwen
- Andy McDonald Contact Middlesbrough and Thornaby East
- Andy Slaughter Contact Hammersmith and Chiswick
- Angela Rayner Contact Ashton-under-Lyne
- Anna Dixon Contact Shipley
- Anna Gelderd Contact South East Cornwall
- Anna McMorrin Contact Cardiff North
- Apsana Begum Contact Poplar and Limehouse
- Ashley Dalton Contact West Lancashire
- Bambos Charalambous Contact Southgate and Wood Green
- Barry Gardiner Contact Brent West
- Becky Gittins Contact Clwyd East
- Ben Goldsborough Contact South Norfolk
- Bill Esterson Contact Sefton Central
- Blair McDougall Contact East Renfrewshire
- Callum Anderson Contact Buckingham and Bletchley
- Carolyn Harris Contact Neath and Swansea East
- Cat Eccles Contact Stourbridge
- Cat Smith Contact Lancaster and Wyre
- Catherine Atkinson Contact Derby North
- Catherine McKinnell Contact Newcastle upon Tyne North
- Charlotte Nichols Contact Warrington North
- Chris Bryant Contact Rhondda and Ogmore
- Chris Curtis Contact Milton Keynes North
- Chris Elmore Contact Bridgend
- Chris Kane Contact Stirling and Strathallan
- Chris McDonald Contact Stockton North
- Chris Murray Contact Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
- Chris Webb Contact Blackpool South
- Christian Wakeford Contact Bury South
- Claire Hazelgrove Contact Filton and Bradley Stoke
- Claire Hughes Contact Bangor Aberconwy
- Clive Efford Contact Eltham and Chislehurst
- Clive Lewis Contact Norwich South
- Connor Naismith Contact Crewe and Nantwich
- Dame Angela Eagle Contact Wallasey
- Dame Diana Johnson Contact Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham
- Dame Nia Griffith Contact Llanelli
- Damien Egan Contact Bristol North East
- Dan Aldridge Contact Weston-super-Mare
- Dan Carden Contact Liverpool Walton
- Dan Jarvis Contact Barnsley North
- Dan Tomlinson Contact Chipping Barnet
- Daniel Francis Contact Bexleyheath and Crayford
- Daniel Zeichner Contact Cambridge
- Danny Beales Contact Uxbridge and South Ruislip
- Darren Jones Contact Bristol North West
- Darren Paffey Contact Southampton Itchen
- Dave Robertson Contact Lichfield
- David Baines Contact St Helens North
- David Burton-Sampson Contact Southend West and Leigh
- David Pinto-Duschinsky Contact Hendon
- David Smith Contact North Northumberland
- David Taylor Contact Hemel Hempstead
- David Williams Contact Stoke-on-Trent North
- Dawn Butler Contact Brent East
- Debbie Abrahams Contact Oldham East and Saddleworth
- Deirdre Costigan Contact Ealing Southall
- Derek Twigg Contact Widnes and Halewood
- Douglas McAllister Contact West Dunbartonshire
- Dr Beccy Cooper Contact Worthing West
- Dr Jeevun Sandher Contact Loughborough
- Dr Lauren Sullivan Contact Gravesham
- Dr Marie Tidball Contact Penistone and Stocksbridge
- Dr Rupa Huq Contact Ealing Central and Acton
- Dr Scott Arthur Contact Edinburgh South West
- Dr Simon Opher Contact Stroud
- Dr Zubir Ahmed Contact Glasgow South West
- Ed Miliband Contact Doncaster North
- Ellie Reeves Contact Lewisham West and East Dulwich
- Emily Thornberry Contact Islington South and Finsbury
- Emma Hardy Contact Kingston upon Hull West and Haltemprice
- Emma Lewell Contact South Shields
- Emma Reynolds Contact Wycombe
- Euan Stainbank Contact Falkirk
- Fabian Hamilton Contact Leeds North East
- Fleur Anderson Contact Putney
- Frank McNally Contact Coatbridge and Bellshill
- Fred Thomas Contact Plymouth Moor View
- Gen Kitchen Contact Wellingborough and Rushden
- Georgia Gould Contact Queen's Park and Maida Vale
- Gerald Jones Contact Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare
- Gill Furniss Contact Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough
- Gordon McKee Contact Glasgow South
- Graeme Downie Contact Dunfermline and Dollar
- Graham Stringer Contact Blackley and Middleton South
- Grahame Morris Contact Easington
- Gregor Poynton Contact Livingston
- Gurinder Singh Josan Contact Smethwick
- Harpreet Uppal Contact Huddersfield
- Heidi Alexander Contact Swindon South
- Helen Hayes Contact Dulwich and West Norwood
- Henry Tufnell Contact Mid and South Pembrokeshire
- Hilary Benn Contact Leeds South
- Ian Byrne Contact Liverpool West Derby
- Ian Lavery Contact Blyth and Ashington
- Ian Murray Contact Edinburgh South
- Imogen Walker Contact Hamilton and Clyde Valley
- Imran Hussain Contact Bradford East
- Irene Campbell Contact North Ayrshire and Arran
- Jacob Collier Contact Burton and Uttoxeter
- Jake Richards Contact Rother Valley
- James Asser Contact West Ham and Beckton
- Janet Daby Contact Lewisham East
- Jas Athwal Contact Ilford South
- Jeff Smith Contact Manchester Withington
- Jen Craft Contact Thurrock
- Jess Asato Contact Lowestoft
- Jess Phillips Contact Birmingham Yardley
- Jessica Morden Contact Newport East
- Jessica Toale Contact Bournemouth West
- Jim Dickson Contact Dartford
- Jo Stevens Contact Cardiff East
- Jo White Contact Bassetlaw
- Jodie Gosling Contact Nuneaton
- Joe Morris Contact Hexham
- Johanna Baxter Contact Paisley and Renfrewshire South
- John Grady Contact Glasgow East
- John Healey Contact Rawmarsh and Conisbrough
- John Slinger Contact Rugby
- John Whitby Contact Derbyshire Dales
- Jon Pearce Contact High Peak
- Jon Trickett Contact Normanton and Hemsworth
- Jonathan Davies Contact Mid Derbyshire
- Jonathan Hinder Contact Pendle and Clitheroe
- Josh Dean Contact Hertford and Stortford
- Josh Fenton-Glynn Contact Calder Valley
- Josh MacAlister Contact Whitehaven and Workington
- Josh Newbury Contact Cannock Chase
- Julia Buckley Contact Shrewsbury
- Juliet Campbell Contact Broxtowe
- Justin Madders Contact Ellesmere Port and Bromborough
- Karin Smyth Contact Bristol South
- Kate Osborne Contact Jarrow and Gateshead East
- Katie White Contact Leeds North West
- Katrina Murray Contact Cumbernauld and Kirkintilloch
- Kenneth Stevenson Contact Airdrie and Shotts
- Kerry McCarthy Contact Bristol East
- Kevin Bonavia Contact Stevenage
- Kevin McKenna Contact Sittingbourne and Sheppey
- Kim Johnson Contact Liverpool Riverside
- Kim Leadbeater Contact Spen Valley
- Kirith Entwistle Contact Bolton North East
- Laura Kyrke-Smith Contact Aylesbury
- Lauren Edwards Contact Rochester and Strood
- Laurence Turner Contact Birmingham Northfield
- Lee Barron Contact Corby and East Northamptonshire
- Lee Pitcher Contact Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme
- Leigh Ingham Contact Stafford
- Lewis Atkinson Contact Sunderland Central
- Lilian Greenwood Contact Nottingham South
- Lisa Nandy Contact Wigan
- Liz Kendall Contact Leicester West
- Liz Twist Contact Blaydon and Consett
- Lizzi Collinge Contact Morecambe and Lunesdale
- Lloyd Hatton Contact South Dorset
- Lola McEvoy Contact Darlington
- Louise Sandher-Jones Contact North East Derbyshire
- Lucy Rigby Contact Northampton North
- Luke Akehurst Contact North Durham
- Luke Murphy Contact Basingstoke
- Luke Myer Contact Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland
- Margaret Mullane Contact Dagenham and Rainham
- Mark Ferguson Contact Gateshead Central and Whickham
- Mark Sewards Contact Leeds South West and Morley
- Markus Campbell-Savours Contact Penrith and Solway
- Martin McCluskey Contact Inverclyde and Renfrewshire West
- Martin Rhodes Contact Glasgow North
- Mary Creagh Contact Coventry East
- Mary Glindon Contact Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend
- Mary Kelly Foy Contact City of Durham
- Matt Bishop Contact Forest of Dean
- Matt Rodda Contact Reading Central
- Matt Turmaine Contact Watford
- Matt Western Contact Warwick and Leamington
- Matthew Patrick Contact Wirral West
- Matthew Pennycook Contact Greenwich and Woolwich
- Maya Ellis Contact Ribble Valley
- Melanie Onn Contact Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes
- Melanie Ward Contact Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy
- Michael Shanks Contact Rutherglen
- Michael Wheeler Contact Worsley and Eccles
- Michelle Scrogham Contact Barrow and Furness
- Michelle Welsh Contact Sherwood Forest
- Mike Kane Contact Wythenshawe and Sale East
- Mike Reader Contact Northampton South
- Mike Tapp Contact Dover and Deal
- Mohammad Yasin Contact Bedford
- Mr Alex Barros-Curtis Contact Cardiff West
- Mr Bayo Alaba Contact Southend East and Rochford
- Mr Clive Betts Contact Sheffield South East
- Mr Jonathan Brash Contact Hartlepool
- Mr Luke Charters Contact York Outer
- Mr Paul Foster Contact South Ribble
- Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi Contact Slough
- Mr Toby Perkins Contact Chesterfield
- Mrs Elsie Blundell Contact Heywood and Middleton North
- Mrs Sharon Hodgson Contact Washington and Gateshead South
- Ms Abena Oppong-Asare Contact Erith and Thamesmead
- Ms Julie Minns Contact Carlisle
- Ms Marie Rimmer Contact St Helens South and Whiston
- Ms Polly Billington Contact East Thanet
- Nadia Whittome Contact Nottingham East
- Natasha Irons Contact Croydon East
- Naushabah Khan Contact Gillingham and Rainham
- Navendu Mishra Contact Stockport
- Naz Shah Contact Bradford West
- Neil Coyle Contact Bermondsey and Old Southwark
- Neil Duncan-Jordan Contact Poole
- Nick Smith Contact Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney
- Noah Law Contact St Austell and Newquay
- Olivia Blake Contact Sheffield Hallam
- Pam Cox Contact Colchester
- Pamela Nash Contact Motherwell, Wishaw and Carluke
- Patricia Ferguson Contact Glasgow West
- Patrick Hurley Contact Southport
- Paul Davies Contact Colne Valley
- Paula Barker Contact Liverpool Wavertree
- Perran Moon Contact Camborne and Redruth
- Peter Kyle Contact Hove and Portslade
- Peter Prinsley Contact Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket
- Peter Swallow Contact Bracknell
- Phil Brickell Contact Bolton West
- Rachel Hopkins Contact Luton South and South Bedfordshire
- Rachel Reeves Contact Leeds West and Pudsey
- Rachel Taylor Contact North Warwickshire and Bedworth
- Rebecca Long Bailey Contact Salford
- Richard Baker Contact Glenrothes and Mid Fife
- Richard Burgon Contact Leeds East
- Richard Quigley Contact Isle of Wight West
- Rosie Wrighting Contact Kettering
- Rushanara Ali Contact Bethnal Green and Stepney
- Ruth Cadbury Contact Brentford and Isleworth
- Sadik Al-Hassan Contact North Somerset
- Sam Carling Contact North West Cambridgeshire
- Sam Rushworth Contact Bishop Auckland
- Samantha Dixon Contact Chester North and Neston
- Sarah Champion Contact Rotherham
- Sarah Coombes Contact West Bromwich
- Sarah Jones Contact Croydon West
- Sarah Owen Contact Luton North
- Sarah Russell Contact Congleton
- Sarah Sackman Contact Finchley and Golders Green
- Satvir Kaur Contact Southampton Test
- Sean Woodcock Contact Banbury
- Sir Alan Campbell Contact Tynemouth
- Sir Mark Tami Contact Alyn and Deeside
- Sir Nicholas Dakin Contact Scunthorpe
- Sir Stephen Timms Contact East Ham
- Sojan Joseph Contact Ashford
- Sonia Kumar Contact Dudley
- Stephanie Peacock Contact Barnsley South
- Stephen Kinnock Contact Aberafan Maesteg
- Stephen Morgan Contact Portsmouth South
- Steve Race Contact Exeter
- Steve Witherden Contact Montgomeryshire and Glyndŵr
- Sureena Brackenridge Contact Wolverhampton North East
- Tahir Ali Contact Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley
- Taiwo Owatemi Contact Coventry North West
- Terry Jermy Contact South West Norfolk
- Tom Collins Contact Worcester
- Tom Hayes Contact Bournemouth East
- Tom Rutland Contact East Worthing and Shoreham
- Torcuil Crichton Contact Na h-Eileanan an Iar
- Torsten Bell Contact Swansea West
- Tracy Gilbert Contact Edinburgh North and Leith
- Tristan Osborne Contact Chatham and Aylesford
- Tulip Siddiq Contact Hampstead and Highgate
- Uma Kumaran Contact Stratford and Bow
- Valerie Vaz Contact Walsall and Bloxwich
- Vicky Foxcroft Contact Lewisham North
- Warinder Juss Contact Wolverhampton West
- Wes Streeting Contact Ilford North
- Will Stone Contact Swindon North
- Yasmin Qureshi Contact Bolton South and Walkden
- Yuan Yang Contact Earley and Woodley
- Yvette Cooper Contact Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley
- Alex Norris Contact Nottingham North and Kimberley
- Alex Sobel Contact Leeds Central and Headingley
- Alice Macdonald Contact Norwich North
- Andrew Pakes Contact Peterborough
- Anna Turley Contact Redcar
- Anneliese Dodds Contact Oxford East
- Baggy Shanker Contact Derby South
- Chris Vince Contact Harlow
- Dame Meg Hillier Contact Hackney South and Shoreditch
- Emma Foody Contact Cramlington and Killingworth
- Florence Eshalomi Contact Vauxhall and Camberwell Green
- Gareth Snell Contact Stoke-on-Trent Central
- Gareth Thomas Contact Harrow West
- Helena Dollimore Contact Hastings and Rye
- Jack Abbott Contact Ipswich
- James Murray Contact Ealing North
- Jayne Kirkham Contact Truro and Falmouth
- Jim McMahon Contact Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton
- Jonathan Reynolds Contact Stalybridge and Hyde
- Kate Dearden Contact Halifax
- Kate Osamor Contact Edmonton and Winchmore Hill
- Kirsty McNeill Contact Midlothian
- Lucy Powell Contact Manchester Central
- Luke Pollard Contact Plymouth Sutton and Devonport
- Miatta Fahnbulleh Contact Peckham
- Mr Douglas Alexander Contact Lothian East
- Ms Stella Creasy Contact Walthamstow
- Oliver Ryan Contact Burnley
- Paul Waugh Contact Rochdale
- Preet Kaur Gill Contact Birmingham Edgbaston
- Rachael Maskell Contact York Central
- Rachel Blake Contact Cities of London and Westminster
- Sally Jameson Contact Doncaster Central
- Sarah Hall Contact Warrington South
- Sir Mark Hendrick Contact Preston
- Steve Reed Contact Streatham and Croydon North