Pension Schemes Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendments 15 to 24, 27, 30 to 34, 36, 38 to 42, 83 and 88, insist on its Amendments 88A, 88C and 88E to 88P and propose Amendments (a) to (f)
Party breakdown
| Party | Aye | No |
|---|---|---|
| Conservative | — | 95 |
| Democratic Unionist Party | — | 5 |
| Independent | 1 | 2 |
| Labour | 244 | — |
| Labour (Co-op) | 25 | — |
| Liberal Democrat | — | 57 |
| Restore Britain | — | 1 |
| Scottish National Party | 4 | — |
| Social Democratic & Labour Party | 1 | — |
| Traditional Unionist Voice | — | 1 |
| Ulster Unionist Party | 1 | — |
Ayes 276
- Dan Norris Contact North East Somerset and Hanham
- Abtisam Mohamed Contact Sheffield Central
- Adam Thompson Contact Erewash
- Afzal Khan Contact Manchester Rusholme
- Alan Gemmell Contact Central Ayrshire
- Alan Strickland Contact Newton Aycliffe and Spennymoor
- Alex Baker Contact Aldershot
- Alex Ballinger Contact Halesowen
- Alex Davies-Jones Contact Pontypridd
- Alex Mayer Contact Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard
- Alex McIntyre Contact Gloucester
- Alison Hume Contact Scarborough and Whitby
- Alison McGovern Contact Birkenhead
- Alistair Strathern Contact Hitchin
- Amanda Hack Contact North West Leicestershire
- Amanda Martin Contact Portsmouth North
- Andrew Cooper Contact Mid Cheshire
- Andrew Lewin Contact Welwyn Hatfield
- Andrew Western Contact Stretford and Urmston
- Andy MacNae Contact Rossendale and Darwen
- Andy McDonald Contact Middlesbrough and Thornaby East
- Anna Dixon Contact Shipley
- Anna Gelderd Contact South East Cornwall
- Anneliese Midgley Contact Knowsley
- Antonia Bance Contact Tipton and Wednesbury
- Apsana Begum Contact Poplar and Limehouse
- Bambos Charalambous Contact Southgate and Wood Green
- Barry Gardiner Contact Brent West
- Becky Gittins Contact Clwyd East
- Ben Coleman Contact Chelsea and Fulham
- Callum Anderson Contact Buckingham and Bletchley
- Carolyn Harris Contact Neath and Swansea East
- Cat Smith Contact Lancaster and Wyre
- Catherine Atkinson Contact Derby North
- Catherine Fookes Contact Monmouthshire
- Catherine West Contact Hornsey and Friern Barnet
- Chris Elmore Contact Bridgend
- Chris Hinchliff Contact North East Hertfordshire
- Chris McDonald Contact Stockton North
- Chris Murray Contact Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
- Chris Ward Contact Brighton Kemptown and Peacehaven
- Christian Wakeford Contact Bury South
- Claire Hazelgrove Contact Filton and Bradley Stoke
- Claire Hughes Contact Bangor Aberconwy
- Clive Efford Contact Eltham and Chislehurst
- Connor Naismith Contact Crewe and Nantwich
- Dame Angela Eagle Contact Wallasey
- Dame Chi Onwurah Contact Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
- Dame Siobhain McDonagh Contact Mitcham and Morden
- Dan Aldridge Contact Weston-super-Mare
- Dan Carden Contact Liverpool Walton
- Daniel Francis Contact Bexleyheath and Crayford
- Daniel Zeichner Contact Cambridge
- Danny Beales Contact Uxbridge and South Ruislip
- Darren Paffey Contact Southampton Itchen
- Dave Robertson Contact Lichfield
- David Burton-Sampson Contact Southend West and Leigh
- David Smith Contact North Northumberland
- David Taylor Contact Hemel Hempstead
- David Williams Contact Stoke-on-Trent North
- Deirdre Costigan Contact Ealing Southall
- Dr Beccy Cooper Contact Worthing West
- Dr Jeevun Sandher Contact Loughborough
- Dr Lauren Sullivan Contact Gravesham
- Dr Marie Tidball Contact Penistone and Stocksbridge
- Dr Rupa Huq Contact Ealing Central and Acton
- Dr Simon Opher Contact Stroud
- Ed Miliband Contact Doncaster North
- Ellie Reeves Contact Lewisham West and East Dulwich
- Emily Darlington Contact Milton Keynes Central
- Emily Thornberry Contact Islington South and Finsbury
- Emma Reynolds Contact Wycombe
- Fred Thomas Contact Plymouth Moor View
- Gen Kitchen Contact Wellingborough and Rushden
- Georgia Gould Contact Queen's Park and Maida Vale
- Gerald Jones Contact Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare
- Grahame Morris Contact Easington
- Gregor Poynton Contact Livingston
- Gurinder Singh Josan Contact Smethwick
- Harpreet Uppal Contact Huddersfield
- Heidi Alexander Contact Swindon South
- Henry Tufnell Contact Mid and South Pembrokeshire
- Hilary Benn Contact Leeds South
- Ian Byrne Contact Liverpool West Derby
- Ian Lavery Contact Blyth and Ashington
- Ian Murray Contact Edinburgh South
- Imran Hussain Contact Bradford East
- Irene Campbell Contact North Ayrshire and Arran
- Jacob Collier Contact Burton and Uttoxeter
- Jade Botterill Contact Ossett and Denby Dale
- Jake Richards Contact Rother Valley
- James Asser Contact West Ham and Beckton
- James Naish Contact Rushcliffe
- Jeff Smith Contact Manchester Withington
- Jen Craft Contact Thurrock
- Jenny Riddell-Carpenter Contact Suffolk Coastal
- Jess Asato Contact Lowestoft
- Jess Phillips Contact Birmingham Yardley
- Jessica Morden Contact Newport East
- Jo White Contact Bassetlaw
- Joe Morris Contact Hexham
- Johanna Baxter Contact Paisley and Renfrewshire South
- John Healey Contact Rawmarsh and Conisbrough
- John McDonnell Contact Hayes and Harlington
- John Slinger Contact Rugby
- John Whitby Contact Derbyshire Dales
- Jon Pearce Contact High Peak
- Jonathan Davies Contact Mid Derbyshire
- Jonathan Hinder Contact Pendle and Clitheroe
- Josh Fenton-Glynn Contact Calder Valley
- Josh MacAlister Contact Whitehaven and Workington
- Josh Newbury Contact Cannock Chase
- Julia Buckley Contact Shrewsbury
- Juliet Campbell Contact Broxtowe
- Justin Madders Contact Ellesmere Port and Bromborough
- Kanishka Narayan Contact Vale of Glamorgan
- Karin Smyth Contact Bristol South
- Kate Osborne Contact Jarrow and Gateshead East
- Katie White Contact Leeds North West
- Katrina Murray Contact Cumbernauld and Kirkintilloch
- Kerry McCarthy Contact Bristol East
- Kevin Bonavia Contact Stevenage
- Kevin McKenna Contact Sittingbourne and Sheppey
- Kim Johnson Contact Liverpool Riverside
- Kim Leadbeater Contact Spen Valley
- Kirith Entwistle Contact Bolton North East
- Laura Kyrke-Smith Contact Aylesbury
- Lauren Edwards Contact Rochester and Strood
- Laurence Turner Contact Birmingham Northfield
- Lee Pitcher Contact Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme
- Leigh Ingham Contact Stafford
- Lewis Atkinson Contact Sunderland Central
- Liam Byrne Contact Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North
- Linsey Farnsworth Contact Amber Valley
- Lisa Nandy Contact Wigan
- Liz Kendall Contact Leicester West
- Liz Twist Contact Blaydon and Consett
- Lizzi Collinge Contact Morecambe and Lunesdale
- Lloyd Hatton Contact South Dorset
- Lola McEvoy Contact Darlington
- Lorraine Beavers Contact Blackpool North and Fleetwood
- Louise Sandher-Jones Contact North East Derbyshire
- Lucy Rigby Contact Northampton North
- Luke Akehurst Contact North Durham
- Luke Myer Contact Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland
- Margaret Mullane Contact Dagenham and Rainham
- Markus Campbell-Savours Contact Penrith and Solway
- Martin McCluskey Contact Inverclyde and Renfrewshire West
- Mary Creagh Contact Coventry East
- Mary Glindon Contact Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend
- Mary Kelly Foy Contact City of Durham
- Matt Rodda Contact Reading Central
- Matt Turmaine Contact Watford
- Matt Western Contact Warwick and Leamington
- Matthew Patrick Contact Wirral West
- Matthew Pennycook Contact Greenwich and Woolwich
- Melanie Onn Contact Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes
- Melanie Ward Contact Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy
- Michael Payne Contact Gedling
- Michael Wheeler Contact Worsley and Eccles
- Michelle Scrogham Contact Barrow and Furness
- Michelle Welsh Contact Sherwood Forest
- Mike Kane Contact Wythenshawe and Sale East
- Mike Reader Contact Northampton South
- Mike Tapp Contact Dover and Deal
- Mohammad Yasin Contact Bedford
- Mr Alex Barros-Curtis Contact Cardiff West
- Mr Bayo Alaba Contact Southend East and Rochford
- Mr Calvin Bailey Contact Leyton and Wanstead
- Mr Clive Betts Contact Sheffield South East
- Mr Connor Rand Contact Altrincham and Sale West
- Mr David Lammy Contact Tottenham
- Mr James Frith Contact Bury North
- Mr Luke Charters Contact York Outer
- Mr Paul Foster Contact South Ribble
- Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi Contact Slough
- Mr Toby Perkins Contact Chesterfield
- Mrs Elsie Blundell Contact Heywood and Middleton North
- Mrs Sharon Hodgson Contact Washington and Gateshead South
- Ms Julie Minns Contact Carlisle
- Ms Polly Billington Contact East Thanet
- Nadia Whittome Contact Nottingham East
- Natalie Fleet Contact Bolsover
- Natasha Irons Contact Croydon East
- Naushabah Khan Contact Gillingham and Rainham
- Navendu Mishra Contact Stockport
- Nick Smith Contact Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney
- Noah Law Contact St Austell and Newquay
- Olivia Bailey Contact Reading West and Mid Berkshire
- Olivia Blake Contact Sheffield Hallam
- Pam Cox Contact Colchester
- Pat McFadden Contact Wolverhampton South East
- Patrick Hurley Contact Southport
- Paul Davies Contact Colne Valley
- Paula Barker Contact Liverpool Wavertree
- Paulette Hamilton Contact Birmingham Erdington
- Perran Moon Contact Camborne and Redruth
- Peter Lamb Contact Crawley
- Peter Prinsley Contact Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket
- Peter Swallow Contact Bracknell
- Phil Brickell Contact Bolton West
- Rachel Hopkins Contact Luton South and South Bedfordshire
- Rachel Reeves Contact Leeds West and Pudsey
- Rebecca Long Bailey Contact Salford
- Richard Burgon Contact Leeds East
- Richard Quigley Contact Isle of Wight West
- Rosie Wrighting Contact Kettering
- Rushanara Ali Contact Bethnal Green and Stepney
- Ruth Cadbury Contact Brentford and Isleworth
- Ruth Jones Contact Newport West and Islwyn
- Sam Carling Contact North West Cambridgeshire
- Sam Rushworth Contact Bishop Auckland
- Samantha Dixon Contact Chester North and Neston
- Sarah Champion Contact Rotherham
- Sarah Edwards Contact Tamworth
- Sarah Owen Contact Luton North
- Sarah Russell Contact Congleton
- Sarah Sackman Contact Finchley and Golders Green
- Sean Woodcock Contact Banbury
- Shaun Davies Contact Telford
- Sir Alan Campbell Contact Tynemouth
- Sir Mark Tami Contact Alyn and Deeside
- Sir Nicholas Dakin Contact Scunthorpe
- Sir Stephen Timms Contact East Ham
- Sojan Joseph Contact Ashford
- Sonia Kumar Contact Dudley
- Stephen Kinnock Contact Aberafan Maesteg
- Stephen Morgan Contact Portsmouth South
- Steve Race Contact Exeter
- Steve Yemm Contact Mansfield
- Sureena Brackenridge Contact Wolverhampton North East
- Tahir Ali Contact Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley
- Taiwo Owatemi Contact Coventry North West
- Terry Jermy Contact South West Norfolk
- Tim Roca Contact Macclesfield
- Tom Collins Contact Worcester
- Tom Rutland Contact East Worthing and Shoreham
- Tonia Antoniazzi Contact Gower
- Tony Vaughan Contact Folkestone and Hythe
- Tristan Osborne Contact Chatham and Aylesford
- Tulip Siddiq Contact Hampstead and Highgate
- Valerie Vaz Contact Walsall and Bloxwich
- Vicky Foxcroft Contact Lewisham North
- Warinder Juss Contact Wolverhampton West
- Yuan Yang Contact Earley and Woodley
- Alex Norris Contact Nottingham North and Kimberley
- Alex Sobel Contact Leeds Central and Headingley
- Alice Macdonald Contact Norwich North
- Anna Turley Contact Redcar
- Anneliese Dodds Contact Oxford East
- Baggy Shanker Contact Derby South
- Chris Evans Contact Caerphilly
- Chris Vince Contact Harlow
- Gareth Snell Contact Stoke-on-Trent Central
- Gareth Thomas Contact Harrow West
- Jack Abbott Contact Ipswich
- Jayne Kirkham Contact Truro and Falmouth
- Jim McMahon Contact Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton
- Jonathan Reynolds Contact Stalybridge and Hyde
- Lucy Powell Contact Manchester Central
- Miatta Fahnbulleh Contact Peckham
- Ms Stella Creasy Contact Walthamstow
- Paul Waugh Contact Rochdale
- Preet Kaur Gill Contact Birmingham Edgbaston
- Rachael Maskell Contact York Central
- Rachel Blake Contact Cities of London and Westminster
- Sally Jameson Contact Doncaster Central
- Sarah Hall Contact Warrington South
- Simon Lightwood Contact Wakefield and Rothwell
- Steve Reed Contact Streatham and Croydon North
- Brendan O'Hara Contact Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
- Chris Law Contact Dundee Central
- Pete Wishart Contact Perth and Kinross-shire
- Seamus Logan Contact Aberdeenshire North and Moray East
- Colum Eastwood Contact Foyle
- Robin Swann Contact South Antrim
Noes 161
- Alan Mak Contact Havant
- Alberto Costa Contact South Leicestershire
- Alex Burghart Contact Brentwood and Ongar
- Alicia Kearns Contact Rutland and Stamford
- Alison Griffiths Contact Bognor Regis and Littlehampton
- Andrew Bowie Contact West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
- Andrew Griffith Contact Arundel and South Downs
- Aphra Brandreth Contact Chester South and Eddisbury
- Ben Obese-Jecty Contact Huntingdon
- Blake Stephenson Contact Mid Bedfordshire
- Bob Blackman Contact Harrow East
- Bradley Thomas Contact Bromsgrove
- Charlie Dewhirst Contact Bridlington and The Wolds
- Dame Caroline Dinenage Contact Gosport
- Dame Harriett Baldwin Contact West Worcestershire
- Dame Karen Bradley Contact Staffordshire Moorlands
- Damian Hinds Contact East Hampshire
- David Davis Contact Goole and Pocklington
- David Mundell Contact Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
- David Reed Contact Exmouth and Exeter East
- David Simmonds Contact Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner
- Dr Andrew Murrison Contact South West Wiltshire
- Dr Kieran Mullan Contact Bexhill and Battle
- Dr Luke Evans Contact Hinckley and Bosworth
- Dr Neil Hudson Contact Epping Forest
- Dr Neil Shastri-Hurst Contact Solihull West and Shirley
- Edward Argar Contact Melton and Syston
- Esther McVey Contact Tatton
- Gareth Bacon Contact Orpington
- Gareth Davies Contact Grantham and Bourne
- George Freeman Contact Mid Norfolk
- Graham Stuart Contact Beverley and Holderness
- Greg Smith Contact Mid Buckinghamshire
- Helen Whately Contact Faversham and Mid Kent
- Jack Rankin Contact Windsor
- James Cartlidge Contact South Suffolk
- James Wild Contact North West Norfolk
- Jerome Mayhew Contact Broadland and Fakenham
- Jesse Norman Contact Hereford and South Herefordshire
- Joe Robertson Contact Isle of Wight East
- John Cooper Contact Dumfries and Galloway
- John Lamont Contact Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk
- Joy Morrissey Contact Beaconsfield
- Julia Lopez Contact Hornchurch and Upminster
- Katie Lam Contact Weald of Kent
- Kevin Hollinrake Contact Thirsk and Malton
- Kit Malthouse Contact North West Hampshire
- Laura Trott Contact Sevenoaks
- Lewis Cocking Contact Broxbourne
- Lincoln Jopp Contact Spelthorne
- Mark Garnier Contact Wyre Forest
- Martin Vickers Contact Brigg and Immingham
- Matt Vickers Contact Stockton West
- Mike Wood Contact Kingswinford and South Staffordshire
- Mims Davies Contact East Grinstead and Uckfield
- Mr Andrew Snowden Contact Fylde
- Mr Gagan Mohindra Contact South West Hertfordshire
- Mr Louie French Contact Old Bexley and Sidcup
- Mr Mark Francois Contact Rayleigh and Wickford
- Mr Peter Bedford Contact Mid Leicestershire
- Mr Richard Holden Contact Basildon and Billericay
- Neil O'Brien Contact Harborough, Oadby and Wigston
- Nigel Huddleston Contact Droitwich and Evesham
- Paul Holmes Contact Hamble Valley
- Peter Fortune Contact Bromley and Biggin Hill
- Priti Patel Contact Witham
- Rebecca Harris Contact Castle Point
- Rebecca Paul Contact Reigate
- Rebecca Smith Contact South West Devon
- Richard Fuller Contact North Bedfordshire
- Robbie Moore Contact Keighley and Ilkley
- Saqib Bhatti Contact Meriden and Solihull East
- Sarah Bool Contact South Northamptonshire
- Simon Hoare Contact North Dorset
- Sir Alec Shelbrooke Contact Wetherby and Easingwold
- Sir Andrew Mitchell Contact Sutton Coldfield
- Sir Bernard Jenkin Contact Harwich and North Essex
- Sir Edward Leigh Contact Gainsborough
- Sir Gavin Williamson Contact Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge
- Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Contact North Cotswolds
- Sir Geoffrey Cox Contact Torridge and Tavistock
- Sir Iain Duncan Smith Contact Chingford and Woodford Green
- Sir Jeremy Hunt Contact Godalming and Ash
- Sir John Whittingdale Contact Maldon
- Sir Julian Lewis Contact New Forest East
- Sir Julian Smith Contact Skipton and Ripon
- Sir Mel Stride Contact Central Devon
- Sir Oliver Dowden Contact Hertsmere
- Sir Roger Gale Contact Herne Bay and Sandwich
- Steve Barclay Contact North East Cambridgeshire
- Stuart Anderson Contact South Shropshire
- Stuart Andrew Contact Daventry
- Tom Tugendhat Contact Tonbridge
- Victoria Atkins Contact Louth and Horncastle
- Wendy Morton Contact Aldridge-Brownhills
- Carla Lockhart Contact Upper Bann
- Gavin Robinson Contact Belfast East
- Jim Shannon Contact Strangford
- Mr Gregory Campbell Contact East Londonderry
- Sammy Wilson Contact East Antrim
- Alex Easton Contact North Down
- Patrick Spencer Contact Central Suffolk and North Ipswich
- Adam Dance Contact Yeovil
- Alison Bennett Contact Mid Sussex
- Andrew George Contact St Ives
- Anna Sabine Contact Frome and East Somerset
- Ben Maguire Contact North Cornwall
- Bobby Dean Contact Carshalton and Wallington
- Brian Mathew Contact Melksham and Devizes
- Calum Miller Contact Bicester and Woodstock
- Caroline Voaden Contact South Devon
- Charlie Maynard Contact Witney
- Charlotte Cane Contact Ely and East Cambridgeshire
- Clive Jones Contact Wokingham
- Daisy Cooper Contact St Albans
- David Chadwick Contact Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe
- Dr Al Pinkerton Contact Surrey Heath
- Dr Danny Chambers Contact Winchester
- Dr Roz Savage Contact South Cotswolds
- Edward Morello Contact West Dorset
- Gideon Amos Contact Taunton and Wellington
- Helen Maguire Contact Epsom and Ewell
- Helen Morgan Contact North Shropshire
- Ian Roome Contact North Devon
- Ian Sollom Contact St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire
- James MacCleary Contact Lewes
- Jamie Stone Contact Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
- Jess Brown-Fuller Contact Chichester
- John Milne Contact Horsham
- Josh Babarinde Contact Eastbourne
- Lisa Smart Contact Hazel Grove
- Liz Jarvis Contact Eastleigh
- Manuela Perteghella Contact Stratford-on-Avon
- Marie Goldman Contact Chelmsford
- Martin Wrigley Contact Newton Abbot
- Monica Harding Contact Esher and Walton
- Mr Angus MacDonald Contact Inverness, Skye and West Ross-shire
- Mr Joshua Reynolds Contact Maidenhead
- Mr Lee Dillon Contact Newbury
- Mr Paul Kohler Contact Wimbledon
- Mr Will Forster Contact Woking
- Munira Wilson Contact Twickenham
- Olly Glover Contact Didcot and Wantage
- Rachel Gilmour Contact Tiverton and Minehead
- Richard Foord Contact Honiton and Sidmouth
- Sarah Dyke Contact Glastonbury and Somerton
- Sarah Gibson Contact Chippenham
- Sarah Green Contact Chesham and Amersham
- Sarah Olney Contact Richmond Park
- Steff Aquarone Contact North Norfolk
- Steve Darling Contact Torbay
- Susan Murray Contact Mid Dunbartonshire
- Tessa Munt Contact Wells and Mendip Hills
- Tim Farron Contact Westmorland and Lonsdale
- Tom Gordon Contact Harrogate and Knaresborough
- Vikki Slade Contact Mid Dorset and North Poole
- Wendy Chamberlain Contact North East Fife
- Wera Hobhouse Contact Bath
- Zöe Franklin Contact Guildford
- Rupert Lowe Contact Great Yarmouth
- Jim Allister Contact North Antrim